Top Sag Harbor Hotel Deals

Make the Most of Your Sag Harbor Stay

Historic maritime character

Sag Harbor stands apart from its Hamptons neighbors as a former whaling port where 18th and 19th-century architecture tells stories of maritime prosperity rather than Gilded Age excess. Designated the first Port of Entry to the United States in 1789, that commercial heritage remains visible in Greek Revival and Victorian buildings lining Main Street. The Old Whaler's Church showcases rare Egyptian Revival architecture, while the Whaling & Historical Museum occupies an 1845 mansion that speaks to wealth generated by the sea.

Sophisticated village atmosphere

Long favored by writers and artists, the village maintains an "un-Hampton" sensibility—casually upscale without the exclusivity found elsewhere in the region. The American Hotel anchors the dining scene with legendary status among literary figures, while Le Bilboquet brings French bistro energy to the waterfront. Bay Street Theater delivers Broadway-caliber performances year-round, and the walkable downtown transitions seamlessly from afternoon gallery browsing to evening harbor views. The SANS communities (Sag Harbor Hills, Azurest, and Ninevah) add cultural depth as historic African American enclaves on the National Register.

Exploring the area

The 5-minute ferry to Shelter Island opens access to nature preserves and quiet beaches, while Montauk's surf culture lies 45 minutes east. The Hampton Jitney provides direct Manhattan service, though a car proves useful for regional exploring.

Frequently Asked Questions about Sag Harbor

Can I book hotels in Sag Harbor on Delta Stays using miles?

Yes, you can use your Delta miles for your hotel reservation in Sag Harbor, or you can opt for a miles-plus-cash combination to provide more booking options. Simply log in to your SkyMiles® account, where you will also discover Member-only offers at select properties that could enhance your travel experience.

What are the benefits if I use Delta Stays to book my hotel stay in Sag Harbor?

As a SkyMiles Member, you will earn 2 miles per $1 spent on completed hotel stays and vacation rentals reserved through Delta Stays. Plus, you will receive access to Member promotions at select properties, along with the option to complete payment using miles, cash, or a combination. To ensure you earn your miles, simply sign in to your SkyMiles account or enter your SkyMiles number at checkout when paying with cash. Please allow up to 8 weeks after completing a stay for miles to appear in the SkyMiles account provided. Please also note that if you use miles to pay for any portion of your stay, you will not earn miles on that reservation, including any amount paid with cash.

What is the policy to change or cancel my hotel booking made through Delta Stays?

Cancellation policies vary by property. We recommend reviewing the specific cancellation policy displayed under each hotel's details before finalizing your reservation. Some rates are refundable, while others are non-refundable. Any modifications or cancellations to your reservation may affect the number of miles you earn and receive in your account.

Can my Delta SkyMiles® American Express® Card be used for booking?

As a Delta SkyMiles® Gold, Platinum, or Reserve American Express® Cardholder, you enjoy the advantage of earning additional miles alongside numerous valuable benefits, including an annual statement credit of up to $200 applicable toward prepaid accommodations booked through Delta Cars and Stays. Terms apply. To explore all the benefits available with your card, please visit the Delta SkyMiles® American Express Credit Cards page for complete details.

Can I earn MQDs on Delta Stays hotel bookings?

Periodically, Delta Stays provides special promotions for SkyMiles Members to earn Medallion® Qualification Dollars on accommodations reserved through their booking service. We recommend accessing the Delta Stays MQD Offer page to view current MQDs promotions and examine their terms and conditions.

In order to book a hotel on Delta Stays, do I need to be a Delta SkyMiles Member?

No, Delta Stays is available to everyone for hotel bookings. However, by becoming a SkyMiles Member, you will unlock the ability to earn miles and access Member-only prices and offers. As a Member, you will earn 2 miles per $1 you spend on Delta Cars and Stays (excluding taxes and additional charges). Plus joining SkyMiles is free. Visit the delta.com to join today.

On Delta Stays, can I book a vacation rental?

Yes, beyond traditional hotels, Delta Stays provides an extensive collection of vacation rentals for your travel needs. You can explore a variety of homes, condos, and specialty lodging powered by Vrbo by visiting the Vacation Rentals page.

Which hotels have good ratings in Sag Harbor?

Sag Harbor Inn has a guest rating of 9.4 out of 10, and features an outdoor pool and a free continental breakfast. Another top-rated hotel is Faraway Sag Harbor, where you can enjoy a seasonal outdoor pool and a restaurant.

What's a good time of year to visit Sag Harbor?

To experience Sag Harbor during great weather, consider a visit in September when temperatures are pleasant and the skies are mostly sunny with fewer crowds than summer. For off-peak prices and more deals on hotels, consider visiting during November when the fall visitors have dispersed and you'll find the most affordable rates.

Which hotels in Sag Harbor are near Bay Street Theatre?

The Bay Street Theater stages acclaimed productions in an intimate 299-seat waterfront venue where notable actors perform against Sag Harbor's scenic backdrop. Summer shows sell out quickly. Popular hotels include Mill House Inn which is a short drive away. Another hotel is Topping Rose House and it is within a short drive.

Which hotels in Sag Harbor are located closest to Noyac Golf Club?

This exclusive William F. Mitchell design challenges golfers with narrow fairways and strategic greens across rolling parkland near Noyac Bay, complemented by top-tier practice facilities. One popular hotel is Topping Rose House which is a short drive away. Another top hotel is The Maidstone and it is within a short drive.

Which hotels in Sag Harbor are near Sag Harbor Whaling and Historical Museum?

This Neo-Gothic mansion showcases Sag Harbor's whaling heritage through scrimshaw, maritime artifacts, and period furnishings. The Benjamin Huntting House is a National Historic Landmark. Mill House Inn is a popular hotel, which is just a short drive away. Topping Rose House is another well-reviewed hotel and it is within a short drive.

*Terms and conditions:

Mileage Offer:

SkyMiles Members will earn two (2) miles per US$1 or equivalent foreign currency spent at https://carsandstays.delta.com/Opens in a new window on the base hotel rate for a completed hotel stay. Base hotel rate is the cost of the hotel room, before taxes and fees, charged at the time of booking or upon checkout. Taxes and fees, gratuities, room service other booking charges, or any bookings which are paid or reduced by miles, redemption vouchers or discount codes are excluded from mileage credit. For clarity, if miles are used as a form of payment (whether for all or a portion of the booking), no portion of the booking will be eligible to earn miles under this offer. Except with respect to the Hertz Mileage offer (listed below), SkyMiles Members will earn two (2) miles per eligible US$1 or equivalent foreign currency spent at https://carsandstays.delta.com/Cars on the base car rental rate for a completed car qualifying rental booking (“Qualifying Dollars”). A qualifying rental booking includes rentals at a participating location for one or more days at rates other than travel industry rates or discounts, wholesale of tour package rates or discounts, wholesale tour package rates, insurance/dealer replacement rates, corporate and government rates, group travel discounts, or rentals in conjunction with a frequent flyer car award, or other corporate agreements applicable to the respective car company. Calculation of the applicable standard mileage offer is listed below by car rental company. Qualifying Dollars include the base car rental rate, which is the cost of the car rental before taxes and fees, charged at the time of booking. Taxes, fees, other incidental charges, or other booking charges or any bookings which are paid or reduced by redemption vouchers or discount codes are excluded from mileage credit and are not included in the Qualifying Dollars.

This mileage offer does not apply to stays or car rentals booked through Delta Vacations or any cruises booked through Delta Cruises.

Standard mileage offer for car rentals booked at https://www.delta.com/Opens in a new window or https://carsandstays.delta.com/Opens in a new window:

Hertz Reservations:

• General SkyMiles Members earn 4 miles per Qualifying Dollar

• Silver Medallions earn 5 miles per Qualifying Dollar

• Gold Medallions earn 6 miles per Qualifying Dollar

• Platinum Medallions earn 7 miles per Qualifying Dollar

• Diamond Medallions earn 8 miles per Qualifying Dollar

Dollar and Thrifty Reservations:

• All SkyMiles Members earn 4 miles per Qualifying Dollar

Alamo, Enterprise, National, Avis, Budget, Payless and SIXT Reservations:

• All SkyMiles Members earn 2 miles per Qualifying Dollar